Bill Bahlburg
2/2/2025 4:11 PM
The last time we went into Fisherman's Bay we did so moving slow on a rising tide (a must) and had a soft keel grounding on sand/mud bar that wasn't supposed to be there. The tide lifted us off in about 5 min and we floated into the bay. A local said that the charts are not accurate and you need to watch the local traffic.
Bill Bahlburg
5903
Mike Woolf
2/3/2025 12:38 PM
I've been in and out of Fisherman's Bay many times over several decades in boats with 5.5' to 6' draft, and have yet to touch bottom. That said, I also avoid entering or leaving at low tide and prefer a mid-to-high rising tide, but went in at a 4' (rising) tide last summer. Like any twisty silted channel, the silt moves around a bit and I agree the charts aren't quite correct in there, but they also aren't entirely wrong. In addition to the obvious steps of watching the buoys and your chart plotter location to help ensure you aren't missing any buoys in the circuitous route, I pay very close attention to depth. If things start getting shallower than the charted depth, I steer into a different part of the channel, looking for more depth - and always find it. Yeah, I know you all know all of this, but it's worth mentioning that the bay requires care but needn't actually be avoided.
As to the original question, I do not preserve my tracks and so don't have that available to share. It's not a bad idea, though - I'd probably feel better having a record of where I found depth last time I was there...
Mike Woolf, Oom Pa Pa, hull 4026